BOSTON — Olive Chase owns Casual Gourmet, a seasonal catering company on Cape Cod which had 25 employees, most of them part-timer workers, prior to the pandemic.
“Some of them are students, some of them are single mothers, some of them are people with a second job," said Chase.
Her company is 95% shutdown, she said because of COVID-19 restrictions forcing weddings, galas, and other events to be postponed or canceled.
When the pandemic first arrived, she helped her workers file for unemployment insurance, which is capped at $823 a week in Massachusetts. When Congress passed The Coronavirus Aid, Relief, and Economic Security (CARES Act), it led to workers receiving $600 per week, a bonus set to expire at the end of July but leaving employers in a tough spot as businesses begin to re-open.
“Right now, unemployment is paying them more money to sit home,” said Chase.
She was able to secure a Payroll Protection Plan loan, another new federal program, but said it has not helped.
“Right now unemployment is paying them more money to sit home," said Chase. “In order for me to get PPP they have to go off unemployment it’s not totally fair to me not totally fair to them.”
Chase does not blame her workers for taking the extra money since they work in a lower wage profession.
Michael Goodman is the Executive Director of the Public Policy Center at UMass Dartmouth.
“We don’t want people to return to work too early in this environment where there still isn’t clear guidance from the federal and state government in how to return,” said Goodman.” “I’m not surprised that it’s very difficult to get low wage workers to return to work in this environment."
Jon Hurst, President of the Massachusetts Retailers Association said that, as state government restrictions begin to ease and business picks up this summer, federal lawmakers should refrain from extending the emergency benefits that come in addition to unemployment.
“The best thing that Congress can do is make sure they don’t extend it beyond July 31st,” Hurst said.
In the meantime, Chase has tried to come up with methods of getting her workers back, including the idea of placing them on partial-unemployment or possibly even increasing their wages to give the incentive to stop collecting unemployment.
The State Department of Unemployment posted federal guidance for employees and employers on Mass.gov.
During the current COVID-19 pandemic, the U.S. Department of Labor encourages temporary flexibility to comply effectively with government social distancing recommendations and to mitigate the spread of the virus. In response, the Department of Unemployment Assistance enacted emergency regulations, that, among other things, altered the definition of suitable work. The regulations, which are effective from March 16 to June 14, 2020, state at 403 CMR 22.05:
In determining whether work is suitable, the department will consider whether a claimant (the worker) has a condition that prevents the claimant from performing the essential functions of the job without substantial risk to the claimant’s health and safety. For purposes of this section, “condition” means a request from an employer, a medical professional, a local health official, or any civil authority that the claimant or a member of the claimant’s immediate family or household member be isolated or quarantined as a consequence of COVID-19, even if the claimant or the claimant’s immediate family or household member has not been actually diagnosed with COVID-19.
If suitable work is available, however, the claimant has an obligation to properly apply for or accept offered work. Indeed, recent guidelines promulgated by the U.S. Department of Labor provide that refusing suitable work will likely result in a loss of unemployment benefits. A claimant may not refuse work because unemployment benefits are higher than the amount the claimant would earn from employment.
— The State Department of Unemployment
Download the free Boston 25 News app for up-to-the-minute push alerts
>> Complete local and national coronavirus coverage here
RESOURCES:
- Massachusetts Coronavirus Information
- Boston Coronavirus Information
- Follow us on Facebook and Twitter | Watch Boston 25 NOW




