Survivor of disastrous 1960 plane crash to revisit Winthrop for 1st time

Survivor of disastrous 1960 plane crash to revisit Winthrop for 1st time
The tail section of Eastern Air lines turbo prop Electra that crashed in Boston Harbor yesterday is raised from shallow water, Oct. 5, 1960. Over 60 are known dead in the crash that occurred moments after takeoff from Boston's Logan Airport. (AP Photo/Frank C. Curtin)

BOSTON — It was a beautiful fall day with scattered clouds on the evening of October 4, 1960 as Eastern Airlines Flight 375 lined up to take off from runway 9 at Boston Logan Airport.

The plane would head into the air toward Winthrop, but it wouldn't get more than 200 feet off the ground before it plunged into Winthrop Bay, killing all but 10 of the flight's passengers and sparking a years-long investigation into its engines.

The Lockheed L-188 Electra arrived in Boston from New York City that day and was scheduled to hop down the east coast, eventually terminating its journey in Atlanta.

Content Continues Below

The plane had 72 passengers aboard when it began its flight, which would last less than 30 seconds after leaving the ground. A plane heading into Logan was due to cross paths with the doomed flight and the oncoming flight crew had a perfect view of the disaster that was about to unfold.

According to a report by the Civil Aeronautics Board released in 1962, flight 375 had just begun to climb into the air when witnesses saw "an unusual puff of gray smoke" from one of its engines. The plane turned left abruptly and rolled over its left wing before smashing into the water with its nose pointing straight down.

But nailing down exactly what caused the crash would be a years-long process involving manufacturer experiments and protracted legal battles in civil court.

Investigation

Initial investigations indicated the plane struck a flock of birds just as it left the ground. Wildlife experts found what was left of about 75 starlings strewn across the runway and the surrounding area. It was later estimated that three of the plane's four engines ingested a number of birds.

In the months and years following the crash, General Motors would conduct a series of tests to determine the effect of bird strikes on the motors. Varying amounts of birds were fed into the engines to see how much each could withstand.

According to witness statements and data collected from the recovered parts, crash investigators believed the engines alternately stalled and restarted, leading to an overpowered aircraft that was virtually impossible to control at that low of an altitude. Only one of the engines was fully cutoff, with its propellors being turned 90 degrees into the wind to eliminate drag. Investigators found the lever to 'feather' the propellors -- as that action is called -- having been manually activated in the cockpit.

Two flight attendants survived the crash, including Joan Berry Hale, who is traveling back to the crash site Friday to lay a wreath and commemorate the crash.

Both she and another flight attendant reported to the CAB they recalled "a sudden burst of power" and felt a sharp left turn.

The full report eventually concluded: "The aircraft at Boston, after striking the birds, experience a power loss on the No. 1 engine, which resulted in the feathering of its propellor. The Nos. 2 and 4 engines experienced an abrupt loss and nonsimultaenous recovery of power while the No. 3 engine remained at full power throughout...An Electra, similarly configured could not be controlled with more than 3,800 horsepower on its right side."

It wasn't until several years later that further problems with the plane were made known through civil lawsuits filed by victims' families. According to court filings, the co-pilots' chair had previously malfunctioned, becoming dislodged and sliding forward and back. The lawsuits indicate the chair had been improperly fixed with wire and came loose during the flight. It's possible that movement may have caused the co-pilot to send the plane into its left-hand turn.

The investigation into the seating reveled a widespread failure of seating on the aircraft. Many of the seats and seatbelts failed, having been dislodged and thrown forward upon impact.

Winthrop Yacht Club

Joan Berry Hale was a flight attendant on the plane that day and one of only 10 survivors out of the plane's 72 passengers.

She was rescued thanks to the quick action of members of the Cottage Park Yacht Club. The yacht club sits on Winthrop Bay, yards from where flight 375 plunged to its doom. Martin Rogers and Dick Fulham were there that day and sprang into action, saved the two flight attendants at the back of the plane who were thrown out of their seats.

Joan Berry and Patricia Davis were picked up by boats and taken to safety as the front part of the plane sank in the water. Other volunteers, including several teens, scrambled to recover the injured from the muddy banks of the bay at low tide.

"When I got there part of the plane was still afloat," U.S. Navy Commander Donald Regan told the Associated Press at the time. "A good many of the passengers were strapped to their seats and couldn't get out. The seats were floating. I noticed that their weight was pulling them over so that their heads were in the water...they were all a mess -- blood, broken legs, split skulls and everything else."

Regan, a Winthrop resident at the time, was one of the first to reach to the wreckage in a kayak. He and others pulled about five or six people from the water.

In the decades since, Joan Berry has never revisited the crash site.

A seat at the yacht club was dedicated to one of her rescuers, Dick Fulham, who has since passed away.

On Friday afternoon, Hale went to the yacht club to spend time with the community to remember those who helped that day.

She was also slated to go out in a boat to the site of the crash and lay a wreath in memory of those who died.

The following manifest was printed by the Associated Press shortly after the crash:

FRED ABATE, 18, United States Marine Corps, Quincy.
ROBERT W. ANDERSON, 39, Needham.
MORRIS BARRACK, Philadelphia, shoe firm executive.
JACK BARRACK, Plymouth Meeting, Pa., shoe firm executive.
EVAN BEDIGIAN, 40, Whitinsville.
MARTIN B. BIERENBAUM, 36, Merion Station, Pa., owner of a Philadelphia shoe store.
MALCOLM E. BOTTOMLEY, Methuen.
BERNARD J. BRAFF, Camden, N.J.
GEORGE DEMOURA, United States Marine Corps, Taunton.
IRVING BROWNDORF, Philadelphia, operator of the Royal Shoe Market in Wilmington, Del.
ROBERT DUARTE, United States Marine Corps
FREDERICK FITZGERALD, Hopedale.
GEORGE FRANKENFIELD, JR., Paoli, Pa., an employe of Burroughs Corp.
ADDISON M. FREEMAN, Wallingford, Pa., president of Samuel T. Freeman & Co., a home furnishings auction firm in Philadelphia.
RICHARD ELLIOTT GARDNER, East Weymouth.
HARVEY GOREWITZ, 18, United States Marine Corps, Boston.
HENRY GRANSDEN, JR., Philadelphia, supervisor for a glass firm.
EARL W. HARRIS, Abington.
EDWARD HAFERS, Charleston, S.C.
Flight Engineer MALCOLM MURRAY HALL, Memphis, Tenn.
HENRY P. KING, 49, Reading, Pa., secretary of the American Safety Table Co.
DONALD F. KURTZ, Broomall, Pa., Philadelphia Electric Co., employe.
WILLIAM LARSEN, 20, Unted States Marine Corps, Madfield.
PHILIP LONDON, 50, Elkins Park, Pa., owner of a wholesale shoe business in Philadelphia.
MRS. HILDA LONDON, 47, PHILIP'S wife.
KEITH McMANUS, United States Marine Corps, Leominster.
ALLAN J. MELTZER, Philadelphia.
THOMAS E. MEYER, 38, North Andover.
THOMAS L. MOODY, 40, Philadelphia, purchasing agent for Sears Roebuck and Co.
ROSS BUCHANAN NEWTON, 37, Whitinsville.
LEROY W. NOYES, 18, United States Marine Corps, Tewksbury.
EDWARD F. O'CALLAHAN, Beverly.
CHARLES T. PIERCE, JR., 18, Lowell.
JOHN J. POWERS, JR., 21, United States Marine Corps, New Bedford.
EDWARD HUGHES ROBINSON, 17, United States Marine Corps, Boston.
RICHARD E. REED, Walpole.
MEYER ALLEN SCHWARTZ, Bala Cynwyd, Philadelphia shoe store executive.
THEODORE W. SCHWARTZ, Philadelphia, shoe store executive.
ROBERT M. SCOTT, 52, Northboro.
KENNETH SIMPSON, 37, Cambridge.
MRS. JAMES J. SUPPLE, 70, Boston.
PHILIP STELLAR, 38, Philadelphia, salesman.
HENRY L. THOMAS, 49, East Douglas.
JOHN ALLEN WRIGHT, King of Prussia, Pa.
RALPH WEINSTEIN, Philadelphia, part owner of Enelow Shoe Company.
ROBERT J. DOUGLAS, Marblehead.
RICHARD F. ZELLER, 24, Stone Harbor, N.J.
YENG SOON LEE, 29, Seoul, Korea.
JAMES A. ZOBEL, Birmingham, Alabama.
JUSTIN BAUMAN, 44, Reading, Pa., executive of American Safety Table Co.
JOAN BERRY, Stewardess, Prentiss, Miss.
PATRICIA DAVIS, Stewardess, Jacksonville, Fla.
ARTHUR GLICK, Philadelphia, shoe store operator.
HAROLD HEWELL, Greenville, S.C.
Maj. SYLVESTER M. KOEING, Greenville, S.C.
RICHARD NIX, 18, United States Marine Corps, Sudbury.
ALBERT NORDIN, 21, United States Marine Corps, East Bridgewater.
SIDNEY POPKIN, Bristol, Pa.
JAMES REED, 20, United States Marine Corps, Groton.
DUDLEY A. WARD, 38, Wallingford, Pa., treasurer of Scott Paper Co., Chester, Pa.
MISSING AND PRESUMED DEAD:
Capt. C. W. FITTS, pilot.
M. J. CALLOWAY, co-pilot.
DR. DAVID GRICE, Wynnewood, Pa., chairman of the Department of Orthopedic Surgery at the University of Pennsylvania Graduate Hospital.
CHESTER LAISTER, Swarthmore, Pa.
L. DIERNBAUM, Flourtown, Pa.